Menu
- STARTERS
- Sandwiches + Tacos
- Greens + Bowls + Soups
- Chicken + Steak + Pasta
- Seafood
- Sushi
- Sidewinders + Minnows
- Beverages
- Cocktail Bar
-
Bellie Banger Shrimp or Grouper
Fried and tossed in a mildly spicy honey mustard sauce.
Shrimp $12
Grouper $14
-
Buffalo Shrimp
Fried shrimp tossed in Buffalo wing sauce. Served with bleu cheese and celery.
$12
-
Garlic Mussels
A big bowl of black mussels in garlic white wine. Served with bread for dipping.
$16
Garlic Middleneck Clams $23
Garlic Peel + Eat Shrimp $20
-
Calamari
A mound of tender calamari, hand breaded and lightly fried. Served with marinara.
$13
-
Peel + Eat Gulf Shrimp
Caught on our own boat! Served hot, peel + eat style.
1 lb $25
1/2 lb $15
-
Teeha Marie Fish Spread
Smoked fresh, in-house. Served with fresh veggies and crackers.
$13
-
Sesame Ginger Ahi Tuna
Served rare with a chilled Asia slaw + ginger glaze.
$16
-
Ceviche Stack
Layers of homemade guacamole, seafood ceviche + mango salsa. Served with corn chips.
$16
-
Traditional Ceviche
Fresh fish, shrimp and scallops, marinated with tomato, onion, herbs and spices. Served with crispy tortilla chips.
$14
-
Crab Rangoons
Sweet snow crab meat, creamy blend of cheeses in a crispy wonton.
$15
-
Crab Cake
One jumbo crab cake loaded with deliciously sweet crabmeat. Served atop cilantro lime and remoulade.
$16
-
Chicken Wings
Fried and tossed in mildly spicy sweet buffalo sauce. Served with bleu cheese and celery.
$16
-
Fried Brussels Sprouts
Crispy sprouts tossed in a creamy aioli. Finished with grated parmesan and lemon.
$9
-
Feta Artichoke Dip
Served warm with corn tortilla chips.
$13
-
Steamed Edamame
Choice of Juicy Style | Chili | Lime | Sea Salt
$8
Served with fries.
-
Redman Grouper Sandwich
Served grilled, blackened or fried on a toasted bun with lettuce, tomato, and onion. Served with fries.
MKT $29
-
NEW Major's Crispy Grouper
Panko crusted local grouper, lettuce, tomato, pickled red onion, tangy pickles and tartar.
$28
-
Market Mahi
Fried Mahi, bibb lettuce, pickled red onion, avocado, tomato and cilantro lime sauce.
$16
-
Hard Times Po' Boy
Fried shrimp, lettuce, tomato, dill sauce and scallions on a hoagie roll.
$14
-
Anclote Cluck
Fried chicken, buffalo sauce, bibb lettuce, bleu cheese, bacon and pickled red onions.
$14
-
Double Eagle Chicken Sandwich
Grilled, blackened or fried with cheddar and bacon.
$13
-
Big Beautiful Burger
Hand made and topped with cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato and onion.
$14
-
Uncle Stevie
Grilled onions, provolone cheese, toasted baguette.
$18
-
90 Miles to Cuban
Mojo pork, salami, swiss cheese, pickles and MM sauce.
$14
tacos
Two flour tortillas filled with shredded cabbage, pico de gallo, cheddar cheese and chipotle ranch. Served with black beans and rice. $15 Ditch the tortillas for bibb lettuce wraps. $1-
Fried Shrimp
$15
-
Blackened Catch
$15
-
Blackened Grouper
$18
-
Blackened Chicken
$15
Available dressings:
House (Key Lime Vinaigrette), Blue Cheese, Greek Vinaigrette, Honey Lemon Poppyseed, Honey Mustard, Caesar + Ranch
-
Bellie's Signature Salad
Mixed greens, candied pecans, golden raisins, green apple, red onion, tomato, and goat cheese crumbles. Served with honey lemon poppyseed dressing.
$11
-
Greek Salad
Kalamata olives, cukes, bell pepper, onion, wedge tomato, chickpeas, beets and feta cheese. Topped with a scoop of potato salad.
$13
-
Caesar Salad
Romaine, homemade croutons, parmesan cheese and homemade dressing.
$8
-
Side Caesar Salad
$5
-
Side Signature
$5
-
Side Garden
$5
Additions:
Chicken $5
Shrimp $11
Steak $12
Avocado $1
-
Rusty's Cobb Salad
Fried Gulf shrimp, bacon, egg, tomato, onion, cheddar cheese and a pinch of fried onion straws.
$16
-
Mini Greek + Peel & Eat
Mini Greek salad and 6hote peel + eat steamed shrimp.
$16
-
Kitchen Sink + Greens
Crispy chicken, puffed rice, mixed greens, haloumi cheese, cucumber, tomatoes, red onion, watermelon radish, avocado, warm naan, spicy mayo and key lime vinaigrette.
$17
-
1946 Steak Salad
Mixed greens. tomatoes, crispy soft cooked egg, medium rare sirloin, croutons, and shaved parmesan.
$18
-
Blackened Salmon Spinach Salad
Spinach, chopped egg, bacon, onion, tomato, sunflower seeds, dried cranberries, key lime vinaigrette, and topped with blackened salmon.
$23
-
Little Poke
Raw, marinated ahi tuna, fresh veggies, sesame seeds, masago, avocado, and spicy mayo.
$16
-
The Big Ka-Tuna Rice Bowl
Raw, marinated ahi tuna, jasmine rice, avocado, pineapple, seaweed salad, fresh veggies, sesame seeds, masago and poke mayo.
$24
Soups
-
Crab Bisque
Rich, creamy and delicious.
$8
-
Seafood Gumbo
Mussels, clams and shrimp with chicken and sausage in a rich roux.
$8
-
Maria's Jumbo Gumbo
A big helping of traditional gumbo served over jasmine rice.
$12
-
16oz Blackboard Steak
The best BIG ribeye in town! Seasoned and grilled perfectly. Served with two sided and fresh bread.
$42
-
Chicken Dakota
A perfectly pan seared breast of chicken with sauteed artichokes and fire roasted tomatoes in a light lemon cream sauce. Served over rice and finished with feta cheese and basil.
$19
-
Fat Cat Chicken Cajun Alfredo
Cajun alfredo topped with blackened chicken.
$18
-
Carly Sue Redux
Blackened shrimp skewers over four cheese grits, topped with a cajun cream sauce, diced tomatoes, bacon, and scallions.
$19
-
Seafood Mac & Cheese
Creamy Gruyere and sharp cheddar bechamel over rigatoni with layers of Gulf shrimp and bay scallops. Served with garlicky toast points.
$33
-
Little Joe
A trio of bay scallops, Gulf shrimp and mussels in garlic white wine sauce over linguini.
$24
Make it Alfredo $26
-
Pesto Pasta
A cozy bowl of pesto, fire roasted tomatoes and rigatoni. Served with garlicky toast.
$15
Signature Seafood Favorites
-
Rusty's Cajun Gulf Grouper
Locally caught Gulf grouper atop fingerling potatoes and green beans with shiitake mushrooms. Finished with Cajun lump crab cream sauce.
$36
-
Madame Butterly
Fresh Gulf shrimp, served grilled or blackened with two sides.
$24
-
Rusty's Signature Salmon
Faroe Island salmon, fingerling potatoes, green beans with shiitake mushrooms and finished with warm lemon dill sauce.
$26
-
E. Sea Rider
Grilled skewers of shrimp and sea scallops paired with a fillet of fish. Served over yellow rice.
Mahi $34
Grouper $42
Salmon $36
-
Mahi Piccata
Seared mahi atop jasmine rice and seasonal veggies in a creamy, lemon caper sauce and topped with diced tomatoes.
$24
-
Snapper Due West
Panko encrusted American Red Snapper, fingerling potatoes, asparagus and blistered tomatoes. Finished with a Key Lime cream sauce, fresh avocado and two large Gulf shrimp.
$39
-
86 Proof
Faroe Island salmon and bacon wrapped domestic scallops over jasmine rice, green beans + shiitake mushrooms and finished with a sweet bourbon glaze.
$34
-
Jack's Shrimp Trio
Straight off the shrimp boat! Bellie Banger shrimp, 6 peel + eat shrimp and shrimp scampi.
$34
Steamed Seafood
-
Madame Butterly
Fresh Gulf shrimp, served grilled or blackened with two sides.
$24
choice of:
traditional jack juice, a signature blend of olive oil, lemon + spices
or
eleni's juicy boil, a cajun style mix of onions, garlic, spices + heat (shaken tableside)
-
cedar key middleneck clams
2.5 dz $19
1 dz $9
-
peel + eat shrimp
caught on our own boat! served hot, peel + eat style.
1 lb $25
1/2 lb $15
-
snow crab clusters
weighed to order, a full pound and a half of the best snow crab you'll find!
$36
-
rusty's pot belly bucket
snow crab, gulf shrimp, mussels, clams, smoked sausage, potatoes, citrus + a hard boiled egg for good luck!
$42
Fried Seafood
served with fried and slaw.
substitute side for $1 each.
-
Madame Butterfly FRIED
Our original fried shrimp. Lightly breaded and fried.
$22
-
galilee
Shrimp, bay scallops, clam strips, and fresh catch bites.
$29
-
early out
Mullet fillets fresh from Tarpon Springs.
$15
-
Blue Star
Panko breaded baby bay scallops.
$18
-
Julie Ann Boat Run Shrimp
A hearty plate of panko breaded Gulf pink shrimp. Boat Run = shrimp of all size!
$20
-
New England Wholebelly Clams
mkt $34
-
Fresh Catch Bites
$16
grouper bites $27
-
Clam Strips
$16
-
Calamari
$17
-
fish & chips
Domestic cod, double battered and fried.
$18
Available:
Thursday - Sunday
4pm - CLOSE
* our krab is made from Alaskan pollock
-
Miguel Roll
Real snow crab, cream cheese, avocado, and cucumber. Topped with spicy salmon and masago mix, spicy mayo, sesame chili oil, eel sauce, and sesame seeds.
$17
-
Volcano Roll
Ahi tuna, asparagus, cream cheese, and avocado. Topped with baked spicy conch, real snow crab mix, and julienne veggies in center.
$16
-
Crunchy Spicy Tuna Roll
Spicy tuna and avocado. Topped with crunchy tempura.
$12
-
Fire Roll
Spicy tuna, cucumber, avocado and real snow crab mix. Topped with raw scallop and snow crab mix.
$16
-
Tuna Tower
Spicy tuna, ahi tuna, rice, eel sauce, and sesame chili oil. Topped with tempura shrimp, scallions, sesame seeds, and sesame chili oil.
$15
-
Pauszu Roll
Salmon, krab* meat, cucumber, avocado, and cream cheese. Topped with eel sauce, coconut flakes, macadamia nuts, and scallions.
$16
-
Sponger Roll
Tempura shrimp, cucumber, and avocado. Topped with spicy tuna and sesame seeds.
$14
-
Moo Moo Roll
Avocado, asparagus, cilantro, scallions, and bleu cheese crumbles. Topped with medium rare steak, jalapeno, and chimichurri sauce.
$15
-
Hawaiian Roll
Coconut shrimp, cream cheese, asparagus, and cucumber. Topped with mango, avocado, roasted macadamia nuts, and coconut flakes.
$14
-
California Roll
Real snow crab meat, cucumber, and avocado.
$13
-
Lotus Flower
Seared blackened tuna, cream cheese, avocado, jalapeno, and scallions. Topped with avocado, spicy shrimp mix, eel sauce, spicy mayo, sesame seeds, and microgreens.
$15
-
Sunshine Roll
Smoked salmon tempura, cream cheese, cucumber, and avocado. Topped with salmon, sliced lemon, and masago.
$14
-
Dragonfly Roll
Tuna, salmon, cream cheese, and cucumber. Topped with avocado, vinaigrette mango sauce, Togarashi, and sesame seeds.
$15
-
Long Gone Roll
Panko grouper, avocado, and cream cheese. Topped with spicy tuna, masago, long gone sauce, eel sauce, scallions, and wonton strips.
$16
-
Birthday Roll
Spicy tuna, krab* meat, cucumber, and avocado. Topped with spicy scallops, and real snow crab mix, eel sauce, crunchy tempura, and birthday sauce.
$16
-
Fire the Cannons Roll
Salmon, krab* meat, cucumber, avocado, and cream cheese. Topped with tuna, black tobiko, and sweet spicy sauce.
$16
-
Russell Fields Roll
Panko grouper, real snow crab meat, cucumber, avocado, cream cheese, and scallions. Topped with spicy mayo, eel sauce, masago, and crunchy tempura.
$17
Sides
-
Bacon Brussel Gratin
$5
-
Baked Potato (after 4pm)
$5
-
Black Beans + Rice
$5
-
Cole Slaw
$5
-
Corn Casserole
$5
-
French Fries
$5
-
Green Beans + Shiitake Mushrooms
$5
-
Loaded Skillet Fries
$5
-
Potato Salad
$5
-
Yellow Rice
$5
Minnows
Served with French fries or applesauce. Kids fountain drink included. Under 12 only.-
Fried Shrimp
$7
-
Kraft Mac & Cheese
$7
-
Chicken Tenders
$7
-
Fried Fish
$7
Beverages
-
Fountain Sodas, Iced Tea, Coffee
$3.50
-
Juice + Milk
each $4
-
Saratoga Water
Sparkling or Still
each $7
-
Old Fashioned Shirley Temple + Cherry Coke
$5
Happy Hour
Daily 3 - 6pm $5 HOUSE Margarita + Sangria + Bloody Mary $1 OFF HOUSE Wine $1 OFF Traditional Draft BeerZero Proof
-
Pineapple Mock-arita
Fresh Lime, pineapple, soda + salted rim.
$7
-
Blue Lagoon
Lemonade, blue raspberry, Sprite + Gummie Fish.
$7
-
Blackberry Vanilla Fizz
Sweet tea, fresh lemonade + black puree.
$7
Authentic Tiki Drinks
Our signature rum blend consists of premium Jamaican + Martinique rums. Blending rums is an homage to flavor profiles found in authentic, mid-century tiki drinks. Enter the Tiki Grotto with caution as these pack a punch!-
Authentic Mai Tai*
An ode to Trader Vic’s! RB rum blend, housemade orgeat + fresh lime! *contains nuts
$16
-
FAT BOB
RB rum blend, pineapple juice, orange juice, honey ginger syrup + coconut cream.
$16
-
Goombay Smash
An island classic. RB rum blend, apricot brandy, orange juice, pineapple juice, grenadine + coconut cream.
$14
Signature Cocktails
-
Full Bellie Bloody Mary
spicy vodka, Gulf shrimp, bacon, veggies + a hushpuppy skewer.
$14
-
House Sangria
Housemade with seasonal fruit + cinnamon.
Glass $9
Pitcher $25
-
White Sangria
Housemade with seasonal fruit.
Glass $9
Pitcher $25
-
Tarpon Mule
Tito's Vodka, ginger beer, lime + candied ginger.
$12
-
Key Lime Pie Martini
RumChata, vanilla vodka, key lime + a graham cracker rim.
$14
-
Smoke Signals
Bulleit Rye Whiskey, orange, cherry + smoked cedar.
$14
-
Fired Apple Manhattan
Maker's Mark Bourbon, apple liqueur, vermouth, bitters + smoked cedar.
$14
-
Cucumber Basil Gimlet
Hendrick's Gin, St. Germain, fresh basil, cucumbers + ginger beer.
$12
-
3 Lime Skinny Margarita
Libelula Tequila, Tippler’s, agave, fresh lime juice.
$14
-
Pink Mango Margarita
Margaritaville Last Mango Tequila, Tippler’s + cranberry.
$12
-
Spicy Margarita
Tanteo Jalapeño Tequila, Tippler’s + lime.
$12
-
Prickly Pair Margarita
Libelula Tequila, prickly pear puree, fresh lime juice, fresh ruby red grapefruit, sparkling tonic + a salted rim.
$12
-
House Mojito
Flor de Caña Rum, mint + lime. available flavors: blackberry | strawberry | peach
$12
-
Coconut Mojito
RumHaven Coconut Rum, coconut cream, muddled mint, lime + graham cracker rim.
$12
Extras
-
original frose
A frozen delight of rosé, peach, strawberry + vodka.
$12
-
San Frose
The local favorite! Swirled layers of Frosé + signature house sangria.
$12
-
Pineapple Mock-arita
Fresh lime, pineapple soda + salted rim.
$7
-
Blue Lagoon
Lemonade, blue raspberry, Sprite + gummie fish.
$7
-
Blackberry Vanilla Fizz
Sweet tea, fresh lemonade + blackberry puree.
$7